top of page

The Guilt Trap: Why Setting Boundaries Feels Wrong (and Why It’s Not)

Updated: Feb 27

Do you ever set a boundary and then immediately feel guilty, like you’ve going to get in trouble? You’re not alone. So many people struggle with the idea that saying ‘no’ or asking for space is somehow selfish. But spoiler alert—it’s not.



A woman in black stands before two judges in a courtroom. Wooden furniture and scales emblem on the bench suggest a formal setting.
No Judge, No Jury: You don't need to justify your boundaries.

Why Does Setting Boundaries Feel So Hard?

From a young age, many of us were conditioned to believe that being "good" meant being agreeable, helpful, and always putting others first.


🤝 Did you grow up in a household where saying ‘no’ led to guilt trips?

😬 Were you taught that prioritizing yourself was "selfish"?

😔 Do you feel like maintaining relationships means always being available?


If so, it’s no wonder that setting boundaries feels wrong—your brain associates it with rejection, conflict, or disappointment.


Boundary Guilt = A Trauma Response

When we’re young, our survival depends on staying connected to caregivers and social groups. If you learned that saying ‘no’ led to rejection, disappointment, or emotional withdrawal, your nervous system might now perceive boundaries as a threat. This is especially true if you experienced emotional neglect, enmeshment, or were the “fixer” in your family.


How to Reframe Boundaries as Self-Respect

Boundaries aren’t walls—they’re doors. They don’t shut people out; they allow relationships to thrive with mutual respect.


🚪 Boundaries keep resentment from building. When you constantly say yes out of obligation, resentment creeps in.

🧠 They teach others how to treat you. When you show that you value your own needs, others will too.

❤️ They strengthen relationships. The healthiest relationships exist when both people can voice their needs without fear.

Pink and green door hanger on a handle reads: "Please Come Back Later." Elegant design with a gold emblem, set against a dark green background.
It’s Okay to Say ‘Not Right Now’.

What Setting Boundaries Looks Like in Real Life

Imagine this:

📞 Instead of answering every call or text immediately, you call back when you actually have time and energy.

📝 Instead of overloading your schedule, you say, “I’d love to help, but I can’t take that on right now.”

💬 Instead of feeling like a bad person for saying no, you recognize that honoring your limits is an act of self-care.


Breaking the Guilt Loop

Feeling guilty after setting a boundary doesn’t mean you’re doing something wrong—it means you’re breaking an old pattern. With time, your nervous system will learn that boundaries = safety, not danger.


So, the next time you set a boundary and feel that familiar guilt creeping in, remind yourself: I am not responsible for other people’s emotions. My needs matter too.


Ready to Ditch Boundary Guilt?

You don’t have to do it alone. Therapy can help you rewire those deep-seated beliefs and finally feel good about standing up for yourself. Talk to one of our "boundary specialists" today!



Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

About Us

We are a small group private practice with therapists who offer supportive trauma and EMDR therapy in Charlottesville, VA and anywhere in Virginia virtually.

 

Our treatment approach is person-centered, focused on helping clients feel empowered in their lives.

View our Site Policies

Get in Touch

125 RIVERBEND DRIVE, STE #2, CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA

© 2025 SKYLINE MENTAL HEALTH, LLC

bottom of page